David Blecken
May 13, 2011

Tim Broadbent presents the case for creative Asian advertising

SHANGHAI - In a particularly topical presentation, Ogilvy & Mather’s global effectiveness director Tim Broadbent outlined the case for creativity in advertising and asked why it was still largely lacking in Asia relative to the US and Europe.

Ogilvy's Tim Broadbent
Ogilvy's Tim Broadbent

Broadbent pointed out that “the very best Asian countries” win approximately half the number of creative awards as their Western counterparts despite an abundance of opportunity and talent. He described Chinese advertising as “particularly painful” due to their widespread use of multiple messages, voiceovers and focus on product demonstrations.

He then cited evidence that debunked the myth that Asian consumers were less responsive to creative or emotional appeal than Western consumers; and most importantly, that campaigns that won creative and effectiveness awards on average increased sales up to 11 times more than those that were simply awarded for effectiveness.

The reason for the pervasiveness of non-creative advertising, he said, was often obsolete pre-testing systems and diagnostic feedback that essentially mitigated against surprise, humour and engagement — the very qualities important for an effective creative campaign.

He advised marketers to consider the various platforms available for the rational communication of product attributes in place of TV. “TV is an entertainment medium,” he said. “People get information from other sources, and many channels are better suited. TV is best used for stirring the emotions.”

In addition, he stated that high production values were important as a means of signaling confidence in a brand or product, and that cheap advertising was “a false economy” that hurts sales.

“At every stage of the process,” he urged marketers, “ you can and should ask your agency to do things better; to think in a more creative way.”

Source:
Campaign Asia

Related Articles

Just Published

14 hours ago

Agency Report Cards 2024: We grade 25 APAC networks

The grades are in for Campaign Asia's 22nd annual evaluation of APAC agency networks. Subscribe to read our detailed analyses.

15 hours ago

Agency Report Card 2024: Initiative

After losing marquee clients Amazon and Lego, Initiative faces an uphill battle to rebuild its reputation, leaning on new tools, a "challenger" mindset, and a focus on e-commerce to stay competitive in a rapidly shifting industry.

16 hours ago

Global CEO of WPP Media’s Nexus departs

Bidon has been global chief executive at Nexus since April 2022.

16 hours ago

Mark Read: 'People are happier when they’re in the ...

WPP’s chief executive spoke at SWSW and touched on hybrid working, the future of the workforce with AI and whether brands will return to X.