Jenny Chan 陳詠欣
Oct 19, 2016

CCTV refutes Samsung China claims that Note7s were not flawed

"External heating"? No way, says a CCTV-commissioned investigation.

BEIJING - Samsung in China has chosen a very different approach from the company's global stance of apology alongside exchange and refund options for the Note7 crisis: Namely, blaming the flaming phones on "external heating". But now a report aired by CCTV has strongly refuted those questionable claims. 

An earlier review from Samsung China supervising an independent lab called China Taier Laboratory (CTTL) said exploded phones from Chinese users "did not have battery flaws" and "probably were damaged by external heating", meaning heat sources outside the phones.

Despite the obvious logical flaw in this explanation (if the Note7 were not flawed, surely we would see other brands and models of phones blowing up), Samsung China said the results were corroborated by another lab, Exponent Laboratory. On 19 September and 29 September, Samsung China issued statements about these conclusions on its official Weibo account.

However, in a program about consumer advocacy that aired yesterday, China’s powerful state-run broadcaster, China Central Television (CCTV), criticised the way Samsung tested the phones.

CCTV paid for another round of testing by the same independent Taier lab, using the phones of two vocal local consumers (Zhang Sitong from Liaoning and Hui Renjie from Guangdong) who experienced Note7 meltdowns.

This inspection found no evidence of external heating (please see the above gallery of the report pages in Chinese). In fact, the report stated that damage was caused by "spontaneous combustion" at the lower right corner of the battery inside the phone. X-ray and CT (computed tomography) imaging of the internal structure of the battery showed melted traces of aluminum, according to the report.

Samsung China has not issued any new statements as of this morning.

Chinese consumers have already been angered by their exclusion from Samsung’s global recall of 2.5 million Note 7 smartphones. And even though the South Korean company killed off the hazardous flagship on 12 October, it is just the beginning of what has become the brand’s biggest crisis to date

Source:
Campaign Asia

Related Articles

Just Published

12 hours ago

Agency Report Cards 2024: We grade 25 APAC networks

The grades are in for Campaign Asia's 22nd annual evaluation of APAC agency networks. Subscribe to read our detailed analyses.

14 hours ago

Agency Report Card 2024: Assembly

Assembly successfully pivoted to new sectors like healthcare and achieved B Corp certification. But revenue and operational hurdles must be addressed to solidify its position as a challenger agency.

14 hours ago

Agency Report Card 2024: TBWA

With bold campaigns, record-breaking new business wins, and a near-perfect client retention rate, the agency proved it could lead from the front. Yet, challenges in China and the pressures of rapid growth loom large—testing whether its ‘disruption’ can stand the test of time.

14 hours ago

Agency Report Card 2024: Publicis Media

Publicis Media came in swinging in 2024—snagging big-name clients, racking up awards and riding a wave of regional growth. But with rivals regrouping and the AI race tightening, the fight for APAC dominance is far from over.